To compare fairly, put every quote against the same list of 12 items: product and output specification, the machine list, the links between machines, controls, Incoterms and delivery point, freight and insurance, duties, VAT and clearing, installation, commissioning on your product, training, spares, and warranty and support, then add payment terms and acceptance tests. Fill in each quote's price for each item, or your own estimate where the quote leaves it to you. Remember that machines are often only about 35–55% of a factory project's cost, so a quote that looks cheapest on machines can be the most expensive in total. CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete production lines, and will lay your quotes side by side.

Start with the same specification

Before you compare prices, make sure every supplier quoted for the same job. Send each one the same written specification: your product (with samples if possible), the output per hour and per shift, pack sizes, raw materials, utilities available, the building, and the standards you need. If one supplier quotes 1,000 units an hour and another 2,000, you are not comparing like with like.

The 12 items every quote must show

#ItemWhat to look for
1Product and outputOutput on your product, measured how
2Machine listEvery machine with model, capacity, materials, motors
3Links between machinesConveyors, buffers, tanks, pumps, piping
4ControlsPLC brand, panels, software, passwords
5Incoterms and delivery pointEXW, FOB, CIF or DAP, and where
6Freight and insuranceContainers, sea freight, marine insurance
7Duties, VAT and clearingTariff headings, duty, import VAT, agent fees
8InstallationWho, how many technicians, how long, travel costs
9CommissioningOn your product, to the agreed output
10TrainingOperators and maintenance staff, how long
11SparesFirst set of wear parts and critical spares
12Warranty and supportPeriod, what is covered, response, after warranty

Add two more columns: payment terms and acceptance tests.

Item by item: the common gaps

  • Output (1): a quote that gives machine speeds, not line output on your product, leaves the hardest question open.
  • Links (3): conveyors, buffers and transfer equipment are often left out and can cost a large share of the machine price.
  • Controls (4): unbranded PLCs or locked software can cost you later.
  • Incoterms (5): under EXW you collect from the factory; under FOB the seller loads on board at the named port; under CIF the seller pays freight and insurance to your port, but the risk passes at loading; under DAP the seller delivers to the named place, ready for unloading, with you paying import duties and VAT.
  • Duties and VAT (7): many machinery headings carry no general duty, but import VAT of 15% applies on the customs value plus 10% plus duty, claimable if you are VAT-registered; check headings in the SARS tariff.
  • Installation and commissioning (8, 9): "technician available" is not the same as "commissioning on your product to the agreed output".
  • Spares (11): a quote without spares means your first breakdown stops production while parts come from abroad.

Build the comparison table

For each quote, enter its price for each of the 12 items. Where a quote leaves an item to you, enter your own estimate, marked as yours. Then add the items that are always yours: civils and building changes, utilities, your own staff time, working capital during start-up, and financing costs during delays. The total is the cost of getting from order to saleable product with that supplier. Our guide to import duties on production lines helps with item 7.

Payment terms

Compare payment terms as well as prices. A common structure for machinery is a deposit with order, a payment after a factory acceptance test, and a balance after shipment or commissioning. Payment linked to commissioning on your floor protects you more than payment in full before shipment. Pay only to the account of the company you contract with, and check that payments go through authorised channels.

Acceptance tests

A factory acceptance test before shipment proves the line runs, ideally on your product or materials. A site acceptance test after installation proves it reaches the agreed output in your factory. A quote that includes both, with payment stages linked to them, is worth more than one that does not. Our guide to purchase contract clauses covers how to write them.

Questions that reveal the real offer

  • What output will the whole line reach on my product, and how will we measure it?
  • What is not included that I will need to start production?
  • Who will be on site, for how long, and who pays their travel?
  • What spares are included and what do the main wear parts cost?
  • What happens if the line does not reach the agreed output?

Our list of questions to ask a machinery supplier goes further.

Worked example: three bakery line quotes

A bakery in Gauteng receives three quotes for a bread line. Quote A is lowest, ex-works, with no conveyors, cooling or slicing, and a technician for five days. Quote B is FOB with the full line but installation charged per day. Quote C is delivered, installed and commissioned on the bakery's dough with training and spares. When the bakery fills the 12-item table, adding its own estimates for what A and B leave out, A's total rises the most, and the difference between B and C becomes a question of who is responsible for the line's output. The figures and names are illustrative.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing headline prices across different Incoterms.
  • Missing links between machines.
  • Accepting machine speeds instead of line output.
  • No estimate for items the quote leaves to you.
  • Paying in full before any acceptance test.

Lead times and validity

Compare when each supplier can deliver, and how long each price is valid. A lower price valid for two weeks, with a long lead time, may cost more by the time the line runs than a slightly higher price delivered sooner. Ask whether prices are fixed or linked to steel prices or exchange rates, and in which currency you will pay. Exchange rate movement between order and final payment can change the rand cost of an imported line noticeably. Agree in the contract which currency applies to each payment, and consider forward cover with your bank for large amounts, so the comparison you make today still holds when you pay.

Where CISH fits

CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete production lines, and our quotes show all 12 items, from output on your product to spares and support. If you have quotes from others, send them to us with your specification and we will lay them side by side, including ours, so you can see what each covers.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare production line quotes?

Put every quote against the same 12 items, add your own estimates for what each leaves out, and compare the totals and who is responsible for output.

What is usually missing from machinery quotes?

Links between machines, freight and clearing, installation, commissioning on your product, training and spares.

What do EXW, FOB and CIF mean in a quote?

Incoterms rules that set where the seller's responsibility ends: at the factory, on board at the port, or with freight and insurance paid to your port.

Is there import duty on machinery?

Many machinery headings carry no general duty, but import VAT of 15% applies on the customs value plus 10% plus duty.

What payment terms are safest?

Stages linked to a factory acceptance test and to commissioning on your floor.

Can CISH compare quotes for me?

Yes. Send us the quotes and your specification and we will lay them side by side.