Track record: have you built this line for this product at this output, where is one running, and who makes each machine? Acceptance: what output will the line reach on my product, how will we test it before shipment, and how will we prove it in my factory? Payment: who exactly am I paying, in what stages, and what happens to my money if you cannot deliver? Warranty: what is covered, for how long, how fast you respond, and what wear parts cost? Training and support: who installs and commissions, who trains my operators and maintenance staff, and who I call after you leave. Answers that should worry you include vague output figures, references that cannot be visited, requests to pay a different company's account, no acceptance tests, and pressure to pay before the specification is agreed.
Group 1: track record
1. Have you built this line, for this product, at this output?
Ask for the number of similar lines and where they are. A supplier who builds many lines for other products may still be learning on yours.
2. Where can I see one running, and can I speak to the owner?
Visit a running line, ideally in South Africa or nearby, and speak to the owner and production manager without the supplier present. Our guide on checking supplier references explains how.
3. Who makes each machine in the line?
Many suppliers build some machines and buy others. Ask which machines they build themselves and which they buy, from whom, and who supports them.
Group 2: output and acceptance tests
4. What output will the whole line reach on my product, measured how?
Get a written figure: units or kilograms per hour on your product, with the quality standard, over a stated test period.
5. How will we test the line before it ships?
A factory acceptance test, ideally on your product or materials, with you or your inspector present or on video, and a written report.
6. How will we prove it in my factory?
A site acceptance test after installation, to the agreed output, with payment linked to it.
Group 3: payment and contract
7. Exactly which company am I contracting with and paying?
Check its registration (CIPC in South Africa; the business licence issued under SAMR rules in China), its address and directors, and that the bank account is in the same name. Never pay a different company because of a last-minute "change of account" email; confirm by phone using a number you already have.
8. What are the payment stages, and what triggers each?
Stages linked to a factory acceptance test and to commissioning protect you more than full payment before shipment. Payments abroad go through authorised dealers under exchange control.
9. What happens to my money if you cannot deliver, or the line does not reach output?
Look for refunds, penalties or retention in the contract, and the Incoterms rule that sets where responsibility for the goods passes.
Group 4: warranty and spares
10. What does the warranty cover, for how long, and from when?
Ask whether the warranty starts at shipment, arrival or commissioning, what parts and labour are covered, and what is excluded. Our guide on warranty on Chinese machinery explains typical terms.
11. How fast will you respond when the line stops, and how?
Remote support within a stated time, a local technician, or a visit from abroad, and who pays travel.
12. What spares are included, and what do the main wear parts cost?
Ask for a priced list of wear parts and critical spares, and where they are stocked.
Group 5: installation, training and support
13. Who installs and commissions, and for how long?
The supplier's own technicians or subcontractors, how many, for how many days, in what language.
14. Who trains my operators and maintenance staff, and how?
Training on your floor, with manuals in English, covering operation, cleaning, changeovers and common faults.
15. Who do I call after you leave, and for how many years can you support this line?
Support after the warranty, availability of parts, and what happens if the supplier stops trading.
Answers that should worry you
| Answer | Why it worries |
|---|---|
| "The machines run at X per minute" (no line figure) | No one is responsible for the line's output |
| "Our customers prefer privacy" (no visitable reference) | You cannot check the claim |
| "Please pay our sister company" | Payment risk and fraud |
| "No need for a factory test, we test everything" | No proof before shipment |
| "Warranty is one year from shipment" | Months may be used up before you produce |
| "Spares as needed" (no list or prices) | Downtime and surprise costs |
| "Pay now to secure the price" | Pressure before the specification is agreed |
Check the answers
Verify company registrations, check quality certificates on IAF CertSearch, visit references, and put every answer that matters into the contract. A supplier who answers well in conversation but will not put the answers in writing has told you something.
Worked example: a deposit avoided
A juice maker in Limpopo is asked for a 50% deposit to secure a price. Before paying, it sends the 15 questions. The supplier gives machine speeds but no line output, offers only photographs of other lines, and asks for payment to a company with a different name. The juice maker chooses another supplier who answers in writing, offers a reference visit and links payments to acceptance tests. The figures and names are illustrative.
From a delivered project: A South African food manufacturer that ordered a packaging-line upgrade of about US$420,000 direct from a Chinese factory found two non-compliant subassemblies and a controls package that did not match the contract at the FAT video walk-through; renegotiated milestones protected the deposit and the line reached SAT three months later. Read the FAT rescue case study.
Common mistakes
- Paying a deposit before the questions are answered.
- Verbal answers that never reach the contract.
- Accepting photographs instead of a visit.
- Not checking the company and the bank account.
- Ignoring support after the warranty.
How to ask them
Send the questions in writing, all at once, to every supplier on your shortlist, and ask for written answers. That way you can compare like with like, and the answers can go straight into the contract. Ask follow-up questions where an answer is vague, and note who answers quickly and clearly and who avoids the question. Keep the replies with your quote file.
Then put the answers that matter into the contract: the output figure, the acceptance tests, the payment stages, the warranty start date and response times, the spares list and the training plan. An answer that stays in an email is harder to rely on than one in the signed agreement. If a supplier refuses to put a key answer, such as the output figure or the warranty start date, into the contract, treat that refusal as the answer. A good supplier expects these questions and has usually answered them many times before for other buyers. Give every supplier the same deadline for replies, and the same chance to clarify.
Where CISH fits
CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete production lines from audited factories in China. Ask us these 15 questions too: we answer them in writing before any deposit, and agree payment stages and acceptance tests in the contract. If you are about to pay another supplier, send us their answers and we will tell you what to push on.
Frequently asked questions
What should I ask a machinery supplier before paying a deposit?
About track record, line output and acceptance tests, payment and contract, warranty and spares, and installation, training and support.
How do I check a machinery supplier is real?
Check the company registration, visit a running reference, verify certificates and make sure the bank account matches the company.
What payment terms should I agree?
Stages linked to a factory acceptance test and to commissioning on your floor.
When should a warranty start?
Ideally from commissioning, not from shipment.
What answers are red flags?
No line output figure, no visitable reference, payment to a different company, no acceptance tests, and pressure to pay early.
Does CISH answer these questions?
Yes, in writing, before any deposit.