Buying direct from the factory usually gives the lowest quoted price, and suits buyers with their own engineers, import experience and time to manage freight, clearing, installation and start-up. A local agent or dealer sells machines from one or more factories, often holds some stock and spares, and gives you a local company to deal with; the price includes the agent's margin, and the agent's responsibility usually ends with the machine, not the line. A line company supplies the whole line, sized to your product, ships and clears it, installs and commissions it, trains your team and supports it, and is responsible for the line reaching an agreed output. The direct quote is usually the cheapest number on paper, but the machine is often only about 35–55% of a factory project; the rest, sizing, freight, clearing, installation, commissioning, training, spares and the cost of mistakes, falls on whoever is not covered by the quote. Compare total cost and who carries each risk, not just the machine price. Depending on the project, the line company's price may be higher, lower or about the same as buying direct once everything is counted. CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete production lines for small and medium factories.
The three routes side by side
| Direct from factory | Local agent or dealer | Line company | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quoted price | Usually lowest | Machine price plus agent margin | Whole project price |
| Who sizes the line | You | Agent, often per machine | Line company |
| Freight and clearing | You | Often the agent, sometimes you | Line company |
| Installation and start-up | You, or factory technicians at extra cost | Agent, often limited | Line company, on your product |
| Responsible for line output | You | Usually per machine | Line company |
| Spares and support | You, from China | Agent's local stock and technicians | Line company |
| Fits | Experienced buyers with engineers | Single machines, buyers who want local stock | Small and medium factories wanting a working line |
Buying direct: what the quote covers and what it leaves
A factory quote is usually ex-works or FOB, for the machines on the list, with a manual and perhaps remote support. It leaves to you: checking the machines suit your product and output, matching them to each other and to your utilities, inspection before shipment, freight, insurance, clearing, duties and VAT, delivery, installation, commissioning, training, spares, and fixing what does not work. If you have engineers and import experience, that can be the cheapest route. If you do not, the gaps are paid for later, in delays, extra visits, missing parts and lost production. Our guide on paying a Chinese supplier safely covers the payment risks.
A local agent: what you gain and pay for
A local agent gives you a South African company to contract with, often local stock and spares, and technicians who speak your language. The price includes the agent's margin. Ask what the agent actually does: do they hold stock, employ technicians and carry spares, or do they pass orders to a factory? Is their responsibility the machine or the line? Check the company with CIPC and visit its premises.
A line company: what changes
A line company's job is the working line: sizing it to your product and output, choosing and auditing factories, testing before shipment, shipping and clearing, installing and commissioning on your product, training and support. You have one contract and one party responsible for the line. The price covers the whole project, so compare it with the full cost of the other routes, not the machine price.
Why the direct quote is not the whole cost
Few buyers compare quotes endlessly; they choose when the numbers look right. The direct quote looks right because it leaves out the items it assumes you will handle. Add them up for your project: freight and insurance, clearing agent fees, duties and import VAT (claimable if you are VAT-registered), inland transport, installation, technicians' travel, commissioning time, training, spares, and an allowance for mistakes such as a mismatched machine or a second visit. Our page on whether buying through CISH costs more works through this arithmetic.
How CISH is paid
CISH does not add a markup to a price you could get yourself, and does not take undisclosed commissions from suppliers. Our margin comes from the partner price factories give companies that take on installation, commissioning and support, and bring repeat orders. Depending on the project, our price may be higher, lower or about the same as buying direct once the whole project is counted.
Which route suits you
- You have engineers, import experience and time: buying direct can be cheapest.
- You need one machine and want local stock and service: a local agent or dealer often suits.
- You need a complete line and do not have a project team: a line company carries the risks you cannot.
- Large, complex plant: an engineering firm working for you, with direct buying or a line company.
Checks for every route
- Who you contract with: company registration, address, directors, bank account in the same name.
- What is included: a written list from design to support.
- Output: a written figure for the line on your product.
- Acceptance tests: before shipment and after installation, with payments linked to them.
- Incoterms: where responsibility for the goods passes.
- Licensed clearing: clearing agents must be licensed by SARS.
- Payment: through authorised dealers under exchange control, to the contracting company's account.
Worked example: three quotes for a feed mill
A farmer in Mpumalanga wants a 3 t/h feed mill. A factory quotes the machines FOB. A local dealer quotes the main machines delivered, with installation of each machine. A line company quotes the complete mill installed and commissioned on his feed formula, with training and a first set of spares. When the farmer adds freight, clearing, the missing conveyors and bins, a technician's visit and his own time to the factory quote, the totals are closer than the headline prices suggest, and the choice comes down to who will be responsible for the mill reaching 3 t/h. The figures and names are illustrative.
Common mistakes
- Comparing a machine quote with a project quote.
- No one responsible for the whole line.
- Paying an account in a different name.
- Agents with no stock or technicians.
- Forgetting your own time and the cost of delays.
Your own time is a cost
Buying direct takes time: finding factories, comparing quotes, visiting or auditing, arranging inspection, freight and clearing, hosting technicians and solving problems at start-up. If you or your managers spend weeks on it, that time has a cost, and so does every week the line is not producing. Count it honestly in your comparison. A useful test is to write down, week by week, who in your business will do each task on the direct route, and what they will not be doing while they do it. If the answer is "the owner, at night", the direct route is costing more than the quote shows.
Where CISH fits
CISH is a line company for small and medium factories. We supply complete production lines from audited factories in China, ship and clear them, install and commission them on your product, train your team and support the line. If you have the team to buy direct, or need a single machine a local dealer stocks, we will tell you.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to buy machinery direct from China?
The machine price usually is; the total project cost depends on who handles sizing, freight, clearing, installation, commissioning and support.
What does a local machinery agent do?
Sells machines from one or more factories, often with local stock, spares and technicians, for a margin.
What is the difference between an agent and a line company?
An agent usually sells machines; a line company supplies a working line and is responsible for its output.
Does CISH add a markup?
No. Our margin comes from factories' partner prices, and we take no undisclosed supplier commissions.
Which route is best for a small factory?
Without a project team, usually a line company; with experienced engineers, buying direct can work.
Does CISH supply complete lines?
Yes, with installation, commissioning, training and support.