The monthly cash contribution is the extra sales the line makes possible, minus the materials, packaging, labour, electricity, maintenance and other costs of making them. In the worked example below, a food producer adding a line for R9.5 million all-in, which earns about R420,000 a month in extra cash at full sales, pays back in about 23 months; at 70% utilisation the payback stretches to about 39 months, and a 5% lower selling price stretches it further. CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete lines and gives a landed, installed investment figure for your payback calculation.

The formula

Simple payback (months) = total investment ÷ monthly cash contribution

  • Total investment: everything you spend to get the line producing saleable product.
  • Monthly cash contribution: extra revenue minus the extra variable and fixed cash costs the line adds, before loan repayments.

Simple payback ignores the time value of money and what happens after payback. For large projects, also work out net present value and internal rate of return, but simple payback is the number most owners and banks ask for first.

Step 1: the full investment

ItemTypical share of a projectNotes
Equipment (FOB)About 35–55%The quoted machine price
Freight and insuranceAbout 5–12%Sea freight, inland transport
Duties, VAT cash flow and clearingAbout 5–15%Many machines are duty-free; import VAT is usually claimable but ties up cash
Building and civil worksAbout 5–15%Floors, drains, walls, foundations
UtilitiesAbout 5–12%Power supply, compressed air, water, steam
Installation, commissioning and trainingIncluded or extraCheck the quote
Start-up lossesA few weeks of reduced outputTrial materials, waste, overtime
Working capitalOn topRaw materials, packaging, finished stock, debtors

Our guide to the cost of setting up a small factory explains each block. Import VAT on equipment is normally claimable as input tax by a VAT vendor, but you pay it first, so include it in your cash plan.

Step 2: the monthly cash contribution

  • Extra sales: the extra units you can sell each month, times the selling price after discounts and retailer margins.
  • Minus variable costs: raw materials, packaging, energy per unit, consumables, distribution.
  • Minus fixed cash costs of the line: operators, maintenance, spare parts, insurance, extra rent.

Eskom's standard tariff rose 8.76% for 2026/27; use your actual tariff and the line's measured or quoted energy use, not a brochure figure.

Step 3: a worked example (illustrative figures)

A food producer sells out every month and plans a second line to make an extra 400 tonnes a year of a packed product.

Investment

ItemRand (illustrative)
Equipment, freight, duties, clearing, installation and commissioning7,600,000
Building work and utilities1,400,000
Training, trials and start-up losses500,000
Total investment9,500,000
Working capital (stock and debtors), recovered later1,800,000

Monthly cash contribution at full sales (about 33 tonnes a month)

ItemRand per month (illustrative)
Extra sales1,650,000
Raw materials and packaging−960,000
Electricity and other utilities−85,000
Operators and supervision−120,000
Maintenance, spares, insurance−40,000
Distribution−25,000
Cash contribution420,000

Simple payback: 9,500,000 ÷ 420,000 ≈ 23 months.

Step 4: test the sensitive numbers

ChangeNew cash contribution (R/month)Payback
Base case420,000About 23 months
Sales only 70% of capacityAbout 246,000 (variable costs fall, fixed costs stay)About 39 months
Selling price 5% lowerAbout 337,500About 28 months
Electricity 20% higherAbout 403,000About 24 months
Six-month delay in reaching full salesSame, but laterAbout 26–27 months from start

These figures show the usual pattern: utilisation and price matter most; electricity matters but less, unless the process is energy-heavy. A project that only works at full sales and today's price is risky.

How to make payback shorter

  • Sell before you buy: signed orders or listings for part of the new volume.
  • Size the line for real sales, with space to add capacity later.
  • Reduce start-up time: a factory acceptance test on your product and proper commissioning shorten the ramp-up.
  • Cut waste with accurate filling and checkweighing.
  • Train operators early, before the line arrives.
  • Plan spares so the line does not stop for weeks.

What banks and investors look for

Development finance institutions and banks want to see the full investment, the assumptions behind sales and margins, sensitivity to utilisation and price, and evidence of demand. A landed, installed investment figure from your supplier, in writing, makes the plan more credible than a machine quote alone. If you pay a foreign supplier, exchange control rules administered by authorised dealers apply, and your bank will need the supporting documents.

Common mistakes

  • Using the machine price as the investment.
  • Assuming full sales from month one.
  • Forgetting working capital.
  • Ignoring the ramp-up period.
  • Not testing a lower price.

Beyond simple payback

Simple payback treats a rand earned in month 30 the same as a rand earned today, and ignores everything after the payback date. Net present value (NPV) discounts future cash to today's value at your cost of capital, and adds up the line's cash over its whole useful life, minus the investment. A positive NPV means the line earns more than your cost of capital. Internal rate of return (IRR) is the discount rate at which the NPV is zero. For lines with long lives, NPV often shows that a project with a slightly longer payback is still the better investment.

How finance changes the picture

If the line is financed with a loan, monthly repayments reduce the cash left over in the early years, and interest adds to the cost. Lenders usually look at whether the cash contribution covers the repayments with a margin. Work out both: the project's payback before finance, which shows whether the line itself is sound, and the cash flow after finance, which shows whether the business can carry it.

What happens after payback

A well-maintained line keeps producing long after it has paid back. Include maintenance, spare parts and periodic upgrades in the plan, and remember that a line that runs reliably at full sales for ten years earns far more than the payback figure suggests.

Write the assumptions down

List every assumption behind the payback: volumes, prices, raw material costs, wages, energy, ramp-up time and maintenance. Update the list after the line is running and compare it with actual results. That comparison improves every future investment decision.

Where CISH fits

We give a landed, installed investment figure for each line we propose, specify the line from audited factories in China, ship, clear, install and commission it with output demonstrated, and train your team, so the investment and the ramp-up in your payback calculation are known in writing. Our guide to total cost of ownership adds the running costs over the line's life.

Frequently asked questions

How do I calculate the payback period of a production line?

Divide the total investment by the extra cash the line brings in each month after its costs.

What should be included in the investment?

Equipment, freight, duties and clearing, building work, utilities, installation, commissioning, training and start-up losses; working capital on top.

What is a good payback period for a production line?

It depends on the industry and risk; many owners look for two to four years, but test it at lower utilisation and price.

Which numbers affect payback most?

Utilisation (how much of the capacity you sell) and selling price, then raw material and energy costs.

Is import VAT part of the investment?

It is usually claimable as input tax by a VAT vendor, but you pay it first, so include it in your cash plan.

Does CISH give investment figures for payback?

Yes. We give a landed, installed figure for each line we propose.