Equipment sellers, including local dealers, agents and factories selling direct, sell machines; you integrate them, arrange freight and clearing, and get them running. Engineering firms design the process and plant and manage the project, but usually do not supply the equipment themselves. The right choice depends on your own engineering team, the size of the project and how much risk you can carry. Machines are often only about 35–55% of a factory project's cost; the rest is freight, duties, civils, utilities, installation, commissioning, training and spares, and that is where gaps between quotes hide. CISH supplies, installs and commissions complete production lines for small and medium factories.

Three kinds of supplier

Equipment sellerEngineering firmTurnkey or line company
What they sellMachinesDesign, specification, project managementA working line
Who integrates the machinesYouThey specify; you or contractors buildThey do
Freight and clearingOften youOften youUsually them
Installation and start-upYou or extra costSupervised by themIncluded
Responsible for output of the lineNoAdvises; seldom guaranteesYes, to agreed figures
FitsBuyers with their own engineers, single machinesLarge or complex projects with an owner's teamSmall and medium factories without a project team

Many projects combine them: an engineering firm writes the specification, and a turnkey company or several equipment sellers supply against it.

Question 1: who is responsible for the whole line?

A line of five machines from five sellers can have five warranties and no one responsible for the line. If the filler is faster than the capper, or the oven cannot keep up with the mixer, each seller will say their machine works. Ask each supplier in writing what output the whole line will reach, on your product, measured how, and what they will do if it does not. A supplier who will not answer is selling machines, not a line.

Question 2: what does the quote include?

List what you need to get from an order to saleable product: design and sizing, machines, controls, freight, insurance, clearing and duties, delivery to site, civils and utilities, installation, commissioning on your product, training, spares and support. Mark against each quote what is included, what is extra and what is left to you. Our guide on how to compare production line quotes sets out the items and the common gaps.

Question 3: have they done this line before?

Ask for references for the same type of line at a similar scale, preferably running in South Africa or nearby. Visit at least one, talk to the owner and the production manager without the supplier present, and ask what went wrong and how it was fixed. A supplier who has built many lines in another product may still learn on yours.

Question 4: who will be on your site?

Ask who installs and commissions: the supplier's own technicians, the factory's engineers, or local subcontractors. Ask how long they will stay, what language they work in, and who trains your operators and maintenance staff. Then ask who you call after they leave, how quickly someone responds, and where spare parts come from.

Question 5: who are you contracting with?

Check the company you will sign with: its registration with CIPC or abroad, its address, its directors, and that the bank account for payment is in the same name. Check whether it holds the licences it claims, for example a clearing agent must be licensed by SARS. Contract terms such as the Incoterms rule should say exactly where responsibility for the goods passes.

Local, imported or a mix

Local workshops and builders can supply and support some machines well, especially simpler equipment and repairs. Imported lines, mostly from China and Europe, cover most complete lines for small and medium factories. A mix is common: imported process machines with local conveyors, tanks or steelwork. Judge each option on the whole line, the support behind it and your total cost, not the machine price alone.

Red flags

  • No written output figure for the line.
  • Quotes that stop at the port without saying so.
  • References that cannot be visited.
  • Payment to an account in a different name.
  • No plan for spares and support after start-up.
  • Pressure to pay a deposit before the specification is agreed.

Worked example: a juice maker compares three suppliers

A fruit processor in the Western Cape wants a juice line of 2,000 bottles an hour. A dealer quotes a filler and capper; a factory abroad quotes the full line ex-works; a line company quotes the full line installed and commissioned on the processor's juice, with training and a first set of spares. On paper the line company is most expensive. When the processor adds freight, clearing, installation, the missing pasteuriser link and the cost of an engineer to integrate the dealer's machines, the gap changes, and the decision comes down to who will be responsible for the line reaching 2,000 bottles an hour. The figures and names are illustrative.

Contracts and acceptance tests

Whichever supplier you choose, the contract should include the specification of your product, the output and quality to be reached, a factory acceptance test before shipment, a site acceptance test after installation, payment stages linked to them, warranty terms and what happens if targets are missed. Machines must also meet South African safety rules; under the OHS Act, suppliers and installers carry duties as well as you.

When you need an engineering firm

Large projects, plants with steam, refrigeration, effluent and complex utilities, or projects needing professional sign-off for structures, benefit from an engineering firm working for you. Consulting Engineers South Africa (CESA) represents consulting engineering firms. For a small or medium single line, a capable line supplier can often cover the design itself.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing machine prices instead of project costs.
  • Buying five machines without anyone responsible for the line.
  • No visit to a running reference.
  • No acceptance tests in the contract.
  • Forgetting support after the supplier leaves.

Timing and lead times

Ask each supplier for a timeline from order to production: design approval, manufacture, factory test, shipping, clearing, installation and commissioning. Compare them honestly; a short promised lead time with no plan behind it is worth less than a realistic one. Build your own building, power and utility work into the same plan, because a line that arrives before the floor is ready waits in storage.

Where CISH fits

CISH is a line company for small and medium factories. We size the complete line to your product and output, supply it from audited factories in China, ship and clear it, install and commission it on your product, train your team, and support it after start-up. For a single machine, a local dealer may suit you better, and for a large complex plant you may also want an engineering firm working for you.

Frequently asked questions

Who supplies production lines in South Africa?

Equipment sellers, engineering firms and turnkey or line companies; they differ in who integrates the line and who is responsible for its output.

What is the difference between an equipment seller and a turnkey company?

An equipment seller sells machines; a turnkey company supplies, installs and commissions a working line and is responsible for its output.

How do I compare production line quotes?

List every item from design to support and mark what each quote includes, excludes and leaves to you.

Should I visit references?

Yes, at least one running line of the same type and scale, and talk to the owner without the supplier present.

Do I need an engineering firm?

For large or complex plants usually yes; for a small or medium single line a capable line supplier can often cover the design.

Does CISH supply complete lines?

Yes, for small and medium factories, with installation, commissioning, training and support.